UPDATED: Toronto’s Dedicated Stormwater Fee Delayed

By Water Canada 03:18PM May 17, 2017



Read Later

Toronto has delayed its decision to implement a dedicated stormwater fee, due to cost concerns and the ultimate transparency for rate payers, among others.

When Toronto’s Executive Committee—a group that makes recommendations on Council’s strategic policy and priorities and financial planning, among other things—received recommendations from Toronto Water on how to charge for stormwater, the committee voted to take the report as information.

“The public was asking for [the stormwater fee] to be more discrete than were were ready or capable of providing,” said Lou Di Gironimo, general manager of Toronto Water, to Water Canada. “We use some GIS technologies and LIDAR technologies that give us some aggregate level information.” But, said Di Gironimo, the complexities that would arise from a more granular data set represented costs that neither city council nor the utility were interested to incur.

Currently, Toronto charges for water and stormwater as one lump sum. And while Mayor John Tory stated that accounting for stormwater usage was a “legitimate public policy concern,” he thought the implementing the dedicated stormwater charge at greater cost to the city and without sufficient transparency would amount to replacing one “unfairness” with “a bunch of new ones.”

Specifically, Tory believed new unfairness would arise through anticipated school board exemptions from a dedicated stormwater charge; no guarantees that landlords would pass savings onto their tenants generated by the charge, but most likely would pass on additional costs if they incurred them; and that the cost to the city in providing granular data for each property was not a sound budgetary practice.

“Once a homeowner says, ‘I want you to look at my property, because I know that my neighbour did not do what I did, and I want to pay less than him,’ then you are talking about a level of detail that we just don’t have.” Consequently, Di Gironimo recommended the charge be shelved until it was possible to determine the best method for implementing a dedicated stormwater charge, without generating costs outside of the ten-year plan.

“It came down to deferring some capital and that wasn’t the objective,” he said. “We were prepared to make the investment for what was proposed in the report; that was approximately $2 million in administration to generate $275,000 of our revenue.” But the costs to do the programs that were being asked for by some homeowners, it might have gone up to $8 or $10 million in one year.”

The Executive Committee discussion of the dedicated stormwater charge begins at approximately the four hour, thirty-minute mark.

Would you recommend this article?

Suggested News Articles

News, Northern CanadaOct. 20, 2017
Read Later

Nunavut Water Board Approves Type B Water Licence for Gold Exploration

NxGold Ltd. has been issued a Type B Water Licence by the Nunavut Water Board in respect of the Kuulu Project in Nunavut. This licence authorizes water use and waste management…
News, Western CanadaOct. 20, 2017
Read Later

Comox Valley, B.C. Takes Action to End Boil Water Notices

Decisions made at the Comox Valley Water Committee meeting on Tuesday have set a clear course for construction of a new water treatment system beginning in 2019, with interim measures…
News, Western CanadaOct. 20, 2017
Read Later

Campbell River, B.C. Proceeds with Wetland Water Control Project

Following work to remove invasive plants and regulate water levels as part of preliminary restoration at its Jubilee wetland this summer, Campbell River, B.C. has issued a development permit for…